The ‘Otherness’ Of Kraftwerk

Behind a curtain and bathed in a blood-red glow, the four silhouetted figures of Kraftwerk stand motionless behind their keyboard/laptop workstations. They crank up ‘Man Machine’, its clean, efficient melody booming from the speakers. When some select beats and bleeps are added, the stage – curtain parts a little awkwardly to reveal the four members looking down at their computers, each moving their mouse as if updating an excel spreadsheet. There’s no acknowledgement of the audience. They don’t look up from their screens. It’s quite an intro.

Why does this type of introduction, and their continued refusal throughout the gig to engage with the audience, work so well? How come it never feels contrived or pretentious? Because there is a genuine mystique to the band, an ‘otherness’ that has been there since Kraftwerk’s core members of Ralf Hutter and Florian Schneider (the latter, sadly, is not present tonight) created this completely new type of music all those years ago in Düsseldorf. A band this enigmatic do not stroll on stage. They are revealed from behind a curtain. The live performance paradigm shifts dramatically for the Kraftwerk model and that is why seeing them live is such a thrilling experience.

Strangely, this sort of performance has drawn derision from some quarters. Why would you pay to watch four Germans tapping on their laptops? Because it’s Kraftwerk, they invented modern electronic and dance music and they can do whatever they want.  The minimalist set-up, the vocoderised vocals, the ever-changing Expressionistic visuals on display tonight, the songs about cycling and motorways and pocket calculators and the wry, self-mocking humour are all part of the Kraftwerk concept and that is why we are here. Whether the music is live or pre-programmed is unimportant. Again this is Kraftwerk and the rules don’t apply anymore. For Kraftwerk, everything changes. It helps too that EVERY song aired tonight is a small masterpiece that has stood the test of time, especially ‘Radioactivity’, ‘Neon Lights’, ‘The Model’ and ‘The Robots’ where they are replaced by, yes, actual robots. You marvel at the sheer audacity of it all.

Bono once said Kraftwerk are a ‘great soul band’. People mocked him, of course. Kraftwerk? Soul Band? But he was actually correct. Despite the ostensibly ‘soulless’ nature of the music, tear away a few layers and each song has something to say about the complexities of the human condition. It’s the paradox that lies at the heart of Kraftwerk: it’s easy to think of their music as being, maybe, a little too dispassionate because of its delivery but it is actually full of soul, humour and hidden meaning. So think of ‘The Model’ as a song about unattainable women and unrequited love, ‘Neon Lights’ about loneliness in the big city and ‘Pocket Calculator’ as a sly, humourous admission of their own obsession with machines and electronics. Therein lies the genius of Kraftwerk. These robots have beating hearts too.

Kraftwerk, Dublin, 13.09.2008.


3 thoughts on “The ‘Otherness’ Of Kraftwerk

  1. Deetrom says:

    Excellent comment on the gig at the RHK. This gig was better than their gig in the Olympia in 2004. This was because this was much more raw and Kraftwerk were much more interactive with their machines. Also the screw up with the screens and the curtains added a certain pantomime to proceedings.
    I was at the front for this gig and I can tell you that Ralf and the other guys were initially taken aback by the reception. Generally Kraftwerk gigs are much more sedate and ascetic. This gig was an exception to the rule. The only other gig that rivalled this gig in terms of intensity was the one they did In Luton in May 1997. Seeing Ralf and the lads warming to the crowd and failing to conceal their smiles of pleasure and enjoyment, was a joy in itself and made this a wonderful experience for everybody.

  2. Quint says:

    Thanks Deetrom. It was a great gig despite the technical problems. Yes, I noticed too that they were taken aback by the reception they got – it was strange to see them smiling! They’re human after all! I’ve seen them twice but both in tents at festivals so I would love to see them in a proper indoor venue. Hopefully in 2009.

  3. music4videos says:

    Cool post, lots of info. Pretty sad that Florian is finally leaving the band, I hope they continue to produce cool electronic music. I wouldn’t say that Kraftwerk will be supporting Radiohead on their 2009 tour, it’s more the other way around, Kraftwerk did innovation, Radiohead is just taking the wave (in my humble opinion) … I’ve posted some video of a Kraftwerk concert on my blog you may visit if you like. Kraftwerk rocks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: